Armanino Blog

Combining CARES Act and the TCJA: Changing Your Accounting Methods Could Result In Significant Tax Savings

June 05, 2020

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) expanded the use of the cash method of accounting to business entities including those with inventories if their average gross receipts are $25 million or less starting with years beginning after January 1, 2018. The change is adopted by filing Form 3115 with the tax return for the year the change is to apply and may result in a substantial negative amount for the change from accrual to cash that occurs at the beginning of the year of conversion.

If a negative change arises in the conversion from accrual to cash, the loss is subject to two limitations of the TCJA. First, the loss allowed in the current year cannot exceed an excess business loss limitation of $250,000 for single and $500,000 for married taxpayers. Second, any losses in excess of current year income can only be carried forward and are further limited to offsetting only 80% of the future year’s income.

The CARES Act avoids the above two TCJA limits for accrual to cash conversions for 2019. It suspends the excess business loss limitation for the years 2018, 2019 and 2020. It then not only waives the 80% income limit of a net operating loss (NOL) carryover but allows NOL carrybacks to the five prior tax years if there is taxable income available in those five years. The tax benefit of the NOL could be significantly enhanced by using the higher rates that applied in the pre-TCJA years. For example, prior C Corporation rates of 34% could apply compared to the current 21% rate.

The CARES Act NOL carrybacks are currently able to be filed by faxing the NOL carryback form to the IRS. This strategy is open only to 2019 forms tax returns that have not yet been filed. No provisions have yet been passed that would allow an amended return to change an already filed 2019 or 2018 tax return to adopt the cash method.

Background on the Cash Method

The IRS has encouraged the availability of the use of the cash method for small businesses over the years with measures including Revenue Procedure 2001-10 that allowed businesses with receipts of less than $1 million to adopt the cash method if they accounted for inventories. Revenue Procedure 2002-28 increased the average gross receipts threshold to $10 million for selective types of businesses.

The TCJA cleaned up these Revenue Procedures by enacting the following rules for businesses starting in 2018: (1) revised IRC Sec. 448 to allow C Corporations or partnerships which have a C Corporation partner to use the cash method of accounting if average gross receipts did not exceed $25 million; (2) added IRC Sec. 471 (c} to allow small businesses that met the IRC Sec. 448 $25 million average gross receipts test to treat inventory as (a) non-incidental materials and supplies or (b) conform to their applicable financial statements or books and records prepared in accordance with their accounting procedures; and (3) added 263A(i) to exempt these small businesses with average gross receipts not exceeding $25 million from being subject to the 263A Inventory Capitalization rules.

Other details to keep in mind with the TCJA rules are aggregation rules based on single employer rules under IRC Sec. 52 (a) and (b) that make it easy for affiliates to be brought into the testing group for the $25 million average gross receipts. To utilize the TCJA rules, it is essential for all owners to stay abreast of the ownership positions. Also, tax shelters are not allowed to use the cash method per 448(a)(3), which in turn are not allowed to use 471(c). Tax shelters include syndicates per IRC 461(i)(3)(B). Syndicates are defined under IRC 1256(e)(3) as any partnership or other entity (other than a corporation which is not an S Corporation) if more than 35% of the losses of such entity during the taxable year are allocable to limited partners.

Cash Method Conversions Example

A company has been in business for over two decades. In 2018, it had $15,000,000 in gross receipts and net income of $1,500,000. The net income is based on its state taxable income using the accrual method. Its state does not allow bonus depreciation or extensive use of Section 179. At December 31, 2018, its balance sheet showed that it had $2,600,000 in accounts receivable, $300,000 in inventory, and $200,000 in accounts payables and accruals. It has some manufacturing and assembly involved in the products that it sells to its customers, which are primarily larger companies.

As it considers it alternatives before preparing its 2019 tax return, the company notes that with its average gross receipts of less than $25,000,000, it qualifies for the recently passed TCJA IRC Sec. 471(c} and that it could make an accounting change to cash except for its current method of accounting for inventories. After the change it would have no accounts receivable, would retain its inventory of $300,000 and would reduce its accounts payable to the $100,000 connected to its inventory. The adjustment to cash would result in filing Form 3115 with a $2,500,000 deduction on its 2019 tax return.

In considering its alternatives, the company anticipates that it will generate $1,000,000 of federal taxable income in 2019 and over the next several years.

Case 1: Company is a C Corporation

See attached worksheet. The results are most easily compared by looking at the tax refunded or paid out over the years from 2019 through 2021 when any carryover would be fully utilized. Comparisons are made as follows:

  • Alternative 1 – the loss generated from the 3115 deduction is carried back to the 2014-2017 tax years when the corporation paid tax at the rate of 34%. Federal taxes for the years 2019-2021 including the carryback result in a net refund of $90,000.
  • Alternative 2 – the loss generated from the 3115 deduction is carried forward into 2020 and 2021. The CARES Act suspends the rule that the carryover cannot reduce the taxable income below 20% of the taxable income in which the NOL is applied, so there is no tax until the last carryover year. Federal taxes for the years 2019-2021 net to $105,000 of federal taxes paid.
  • Alternative 3 – this shows what occurs if no cash conversion is done. Federal taxes for the years 2019-2021 net to $630,000 of federal taxes paid.
Combining CARES Act and the TCJA: Changing Your Accounting Methods Could Result In Significant Tax Savings Case 1

Case 2: Company is a pass-through business

The company could also be a pass-through business (an S Corporation or partnership) or a sole proprietorship and the cash conversion provisions of the TCJA and carryback provisions of the CARES Act would both apply. Please note the following based on the example of the company:

  • For the year 2019, the $1,500,000 loss after the 3115 deduction would then be applied to other income or loss of the individual. If the individual had significant other nonbusiness income, the TCJA applied an excess business loss (EBL) limit of $500,000 for married and $250,000 for single taxpayers that could absorb the $1,500,000 of loss. The CARES Act has postponed this limitation until tax years beginning after December 31, 2020, so this loss is available to fully use against nonbusiness income. Note that the 2018 return could be amended to remove any EBL limits that applied in 2018.
  • If a NOL is generated for 2019 after factoring in other individual income tax items, a five-year carryback is still allowed. While the income tax rate cuts were far less dramatic for individuals (39.6% to 37% for the top rate ) than for C Corporations (34% to 21%) there is still more bang for the buck for dollars carried back plus the better result of tax dollars received now rather than in the future if carryovers are used to offset future taxes.
  • Another favorable tax benefit for pass-through entities is the 20% qualified business interest deduction. By using a carryback to pre-TCJA years, the future income in years that generate these deductions is preserved.
Combining CARES Act and the TCJA: Changing Your Accounting Methods Could Result In Significant Tax Savings Case 2

June 05, 2020

Stay In Touch

Sign up to stay up-to-date with the latest accounting regulations, best practices, industry news and technology insights to run your business.

Related News & Insights
Overview of Sage Intacct R1 Release
Insights on the Biggest Changes in Sage Intacct’s 2024 R1 Release

February 23, 2024 | 10:00 AM - 11:00 AM PT
Tech M&A Deals: Achieving Buy-Side Success
Keys to using M&A in your organization’s growth strategy.

February 22, 2024 | 11:00 AM - 12:00 PM PT
Accelerating Ahead: A CFO’s Guide to the Future of Finance
Act now to embrace innovation, prioritize agility and future-proof your organization.

February 20, 2024